Day 3

[Funkii]

Welcome to Day 3 and it is time to decide who you guys all don't trust and who you guys want to throw into jail aka the brig!

Letting everyone know, Belthazar666 is taking Flair's place since he lost interest in the game. I am aware that means that Belthazar666 would know one of Parama's reports, but I have decided to let that slide for now.

[belthazar666]

First post. I'm back

[kelsielove]

Im so confused right now....

[jack]

kels I'm assuming you wanted to lynch, as you hinted, because you had a "guilty" on para. However either 1. You're lying. 2. You were given wrong information. When I said you might be paranoid cop I meant it.

We've lost pretty much (to our knowledge) all of our prs that matter. Tracker, Watcher, clue finder not so much.

[luminos]

At this point, I pretty much want to lynch Kelsie, because it was my understanding that she was soft claiming an investigative role. I would be sympathetic to the insane cop claim, but she outright denied it yesterday. If someone can think of why this isn't a good lynch, tell me.

There are a couple of people I want to jail. I'm pretty sure that at least one of Kelsie's partners voted with her, so someone from that group should be jailed (yes, I know I'm one of that group).

By the interview, I'd say its a good guess that Patricia is mafia. It doesn't really help when we can't reveal our characters, but its nice to know.

[jack]

I sorta agree with you lum; however I don't see why a maf would soft claim cop when they knew they would be lynched the next day. I however am far from saying kel is town.

About jailing wouldn't it be better to jail someone we think is town to keep them safe? I doubt jailing one maf would keep anyone safe or stop the killings.

[jack]

Also I would like to comment back on para's choice for lynch yesterday, ebola. Both her and eric wanted an alex lynch. Just recapping.

[kelsielove]

And im going to claim with 100% certainty that parama is not tracker or was not tracker. Read my posts yesterday to get an understanding of what i mean. Also parama being tracker would undermine my role. I have a feeling parama had the ability to show as a different role on death. And i would also think that parama/belth chose me.

[belthazar666]

tbh seems like you're reaching.

I vote to jail Kelsie, I feel better with a lynch on someone else who's name I forgot. I'll vote eventually.

[Funkii]

Jail Votes
----------------------
Kelsielove- Belthazar666

[luminos]

Jul 22, 2010 18:59:08 GMT -5 jack said:

I sorta agree with you lum; however I don't see why a maf would soft claim cop when they knew they would be lynched the next day. I however am far from saying kel is town.

About jailing wouldn't it be better to jail someone we think is town to keep them safe? I doubt jailing one maf would keep anyone safe or stop the killings.

It could very well be that Kelsie decided it would be better to lynch a town and try to talk her way out of it the next day, but I don't really see why she'd do that either unless she knew that Parama was tracker or something similar. Even though I don't understand why she would fake cop/tracker as mafia, it still stands as my best understanding of what has happened, especially given another point I'll touch on later in this post.

And no, jailing someone we think is town isn't the best strategy. Jailing mafia means we might restrict any special roles they have, where as jailing town gives a signal for mafia on who they should kill the night after the jailing. Alex probably died because he said "Hey, I'm important" by responding that quickly to the mafia's message, and jailing someone that we find trust worthy or that is a town PR could lead to the exact same conclusion; more good townies dead. And we may very well prevent a mafia killing by jailing correctly, if there are only two mafia (doubtful, but a possibility) and we kill the other mafia.

Now here is why I do think Kelsie is mafia, and wasn't just tragically mistaken about Parama. She is making the argument that Parama was still mafia, despite showing up as town. This argument means that either Kelsie is telling the truth, or she is mafia, because if she wasn't, she'd try to find a way out of being lynched via other methods like saying Parama was framed or something. She is basically saying that Parama stole her identity. If this is true, then Belth used to be on the mafia side, and Belth would still know who all the other mafia were. If this were true, Funkii wouldn't have let him take Flair's place unless Flair was also mafia. That Flair and Parama were both mafia, and both were the ones that needed Belth to replace them is rather unlikely. Not impossible, but not something I'd accept without a lot better evidence than Kelsie's claim. Therefore, Kelsie is the best lynch, in my eyes at least.

(Of course, I still haven't given up hope that flair was mafia, but I do now believe that at the very least, Parama wasn't mafia with a weird power to show up as town on a lynch)

Try to show me where I'm wrong, but otherwise this stands
I vote to lynch Kelsielove
I vote to interview Brandon Hopps (second in command and the mechanic? very convenient positions for a mafia team)

[Funkii]

^ Voting now is good and all, but right now we are figuring out who to jail first.

[ebolaeatsflesh]

Im confused as to if jailing a mafia will prevent a kill or not. I do agree that we don't want this to be a way to out a PR, thats how we lost Alex.

[Funkii]

Hello where is everyone? Did you all disappear?

[loveanddinosaurs]

Geez. This board is quiet. Anyway, I have my official votes. I'll be willing to explain them later. I'm getting kicked off the computer as I type this.

I vote to Lynch Kelsie.
I vote to Jail Eric.
I vote to Interview Virginia.